The insanity defense presents many difficult questions for the legal system. Nov 11, 2012 the first person to use the temporary insanity defense was a congressman who murdered the son of the composer of the star spangled banner november 11, 2012 eddie deezen comments you might think the temporary insanity defense was a relatively new thing. Unfortunately, however, the debate has been dominated by slogans and stereotypes and by an inappropriate array of law against psychiatry, retribution against rehabilitation. An excellent detective story in which dan, a paranoid schizophrenic is accused of murdering a young woman. John hinckleys assassination attempt on ronald reagan 1981 became another landmark in the history of the insanity defense. The insanity defense history of forensic psychology. Insanity defense history criminal, person, act, and. The insanity plea is somewhat controversial considering that a person must lack either morals from having brain damage and or an intellectual impairment or have been diagnosed with a mental disorder when the crime happened causing them the inability to follow the law. How can we be sure that a person is indeed insane he could be putting on a show and 2. The result of this effort is the radford serial killer database, a database containing information on 1,737.
Many feel that the not guilty by reason of insanity plea is a loophole in the law that allows culprits to escape responsibility for their actions ennis, 1982. Throughout its history, the insanity defense specifically and the more general concept of mental defect or incompetence have been grounded in the assumption. As a defense tactic the insanity plea cant be considered especially brilliant. A crime of insanity insanity on trial frontline pbs. In the days of the roman empire, the government found convicted people to be noncompos mentis, meaning without mastery of mind and not guilty for. Instead, it was a way for a defendant to receive a pardon or a way to mitigate a sentence. Aug 07, 1983 the successful insanity defense by john w. Background and history of the insanity defense findlaw. When a threeyearold child was found with a head wound and other injuries, it looked like an openandshut case of seconddegree murder. When he was being tried for the murder of one of his many victims, kimberly leach, he and his attorneys decided on an insanity plea, the only defense possible with the amount of evidence the state had against him. Based on a actual 8year love affair she had with an american artist named thelma wood, barnes chronicles the destructive love life of an american heiress in the cultural milieus of paris and berlin just years before the continent would dissolve into chaos. The insanity defense was first observed in recorded history in the times of hammurabis code, which had exemptions for the insane. An insanity acquittal was a showing of compassion and a recognition of the cruelty to inflict punishment on someone who did not know his actions were wrong. The history of the insanity defense stretches back to at least the twelfth century, but initially it wasnt considered an argument for the defendant to be found not guilty.
The insanity plea is a spellbinding tale of the struggle to save a man trapped in a mind like that of john nash, russell crowes character in a beautiful mind. The first person to use the temporary insanity defense was a. The insanity defense derives from the idea that certain mental diseases or defects can interfere with an individuals ability to form mens rea as required by the law. Still in common use is the 118yearold britishdevised mnaghten rule, under which the accused must stand trial and face punishment if 1 he knew what he was doing when he did it and 2 knew right. Ironically, while the insanity plea is one of the most notorious and controversial defense approaches, it is rarely used. The central reason hinckley was found not guilty by reason of insanity for the attempted assassination of pres. Dec 22, 2019 the insanity plea, otherwise known as the insanity defense, is a type of criminal defense employed by defendants, in order to diminish their criminal liability. The use and effectiveness of the insanity plea by serial killers. Multidisciplinary views on its history, trends, and controversies 9781440831805. Oct 17, 1998 after deliberately killing two people, the patient was found not guilty by reason of insanity.
Ted bundy was attractive, smart, and had a future in politics. I read a lot of books and many are interesting, page turning, enjoyable reads but rarely is one so. The primary reason why an insanity plea is entered is because of a substance abuse disorder that the defendant has. This volume provides a clear and compelling introduction to one of the most important topics in the relation between psychology and law. Subjects and method subjects comprised all 15 1 male ngri defendants evaluated for insanity. The insanity plea is a fair and logical plea for a crime 982 words 4 pages. The use and effectiveness of the insanity plea by serial. The insanity defense is one of the more well known subjects pertaining to forensic psychology and the relationship between the mentally ill and the law. Meeting the insanity defense northwestern university. For more than a century, the insanity defense has been the most passionately debated issue in criminal law, the focal point of deeply rooted conflicts as to the function of a law of crime. Vinocour lays out the insanity defenses historical roots, current. Racism in the insanity defense university of miami law.
During that time, he has prosecuted over 300 jury cases including many notable homicides involving the defense of insanity. The insanity defense should be an aid for those people who are truly mentally ill, not just for any average person. Having a mental illness or a history of it needs to be proven by an expert, given the seriousness of the crime. The insanity plea, otherwise known as the insanity defense, is a type of criminal defense employed by defendants, in order to diminish their criminal liability.
The insanity defenses subtitle of the complete prose is a disingenuous disclaimer. Of course, there is a spectrum to how crippling mental health can be for a person, but this isnt just a way out of jail if its legitimate. Barnes herself called this novel of illfated passions the story of a soul talking to itself in the heart of the night. The primary reason why an insanity plea is entered is because of a substance abuse. Since the attempted assassination of president reagan by john hinckley, jr. The history of the insanity defense history of forensic. Only 5% of insanity pleas originate from an organic mental disorder. There are even cases where the accused was proven insane, but was still proven guilty and received a lawful sentence.
Insanity is a highly interesting topic when it comes to the law, and at the same time, is a topic which demands the utmost thought and care. Insanity plea 20140819 the insanity defense is a topic that seems to garner a lot of attention even though it is rarely used and only a few cases that invoke are actually successful a combination of highly publicized cases that use it and the publics misunderstanding of exactly what happens when someone is found not guilty by reason of insanity. Not just for the story line, which is somewhat predictable, but for what the book has to teach. The history of the mnaghten insanity defense and the use of posttraumatic stress disorder as a basis of insanity. There is no definitive study regarding the percentage of people with mental illness who come into contact with police, appear as criminal defendants, are incarcerated, or. What emerged from the model penal code commission was a compromise between the narrow mnaghten test and the generous durham rule. The insanity plea should be abolished because it does not help those who need it, the bar at which you qualify for insanity is near unreachable, which renders the plea useless. Racism in the insanity defense university of miami. Buy a cheap copy of by reason of insanity book by randy singer. May 24, 2017 the most frequent crime that is defended by an insanity plea is murder, which accounts for 19% of the total please. The insanity defense is a tactic that is rarely used and rarely successful. Bloodsoaked philips clothes were shown off in court. After deliberately killing two people, the patient was found not guilty by reason of insanity.
The first person to use the temporary insanity defense was. To obtain a vhs copy of a crime of insanity call pbs home video at 1800playpbs. Flannery the author has been an assistant united states attorney for the district of columbia since 1950. Western culture throughout its long and tangled history provides us with a rich array of images, a remarkable set of windows into both popular and latterly professional beliefs about insanity. It attracts attention beyond its practical significance it is seldom used successfully because it goes to the heart of the concept of legal responsibility. When a defendant employs the insanity plea, heshe is claiming that heshe cannot be. When a defendant employs the insanity plea, heshe is claiming that heshe cannot be held accountable for hisher offense, because heshe is legally insane. Tracing the circular evolution of the insanity defense, from the 19th century trial of a wouldbe assassin in great britain to the controversial acquittal in the united states of john hinckley jr. Psychologist and attorney susan vinocour agreed to evaluate the defendant, the childs. While reason of insanity is a full defense to a crime that is, pleading reason of insanity is the equivalent of pleading not guilty diminished capacity is. Ronald reagan was that, in the federal courts at the time, if the judge permitted the use of the insanity plea, it acquired the presumption of truth.
Allens comic stageplays death knocks, god and death on which his 1992 homage to weimar expressionism shadows and fog is based are omitted from the contents of this anthology. Plea of insanity definition of plea of insanity by the free. The insanity defense a perplexing problem of criminal justice. The idea that insanity could bar the conviction of a defendant arose in the early. The first person to use the temporary insanity defense was a congressman who murdered the son of the composer of the star spangled banner november 11, 2012 eddie deezen comments you might think the temporary. If ruthann aron escapes a prison sentence in her murderforhire trial, she might owe thanks to a 19th century scotsman. The insanity plea by larry d thompson what a satisfying read. Mental health, in general, is a topic that is consistently undergoing further research due to how it impacts peoples lives. The sacred books of the judeochristian tradition are shot through with stories of madness caused by possession by devils or divine displeasure. The onus of proving unsoundness of mind is on the accused, hence the plea of insanity should be taken by the accused or by his lawyer or his family members or previous history of insanity is revealed, it is the duty of an honest investigating officer to subject the accused to a medical examination and place that evidence before the court and if.
While it seems like a quick way to get away with a crime, claiming insanity as a defense is much more complex and unrealistic than people realize. The ruling makes a new book, nobodys child by susan nordin vinocour. The insanity plea goodreads meet your next favorite book. Hinckley, the wouldbe assassin of president reagan, spurred a national concern and indignation at the insanity defense.
This is contrasted with an excuse of provocation, in which the defendant is responsible, but the responsibility is lessened. Plea of insanity definition of plea of insanity by the. As a result of this public outrage, there was major court reform, including the insanity defense reform act idra, which made it even more difficult to argue the insanity defense. Even though there are only 5 states that do not allow the insanity plea, research finds it is used in less than. After a series of murders in virginia beach, newspaper reporter catherine orourke. Racism in the insanity defense hol abuse, and previous arrests. The most frequent crime that is defended by an insanity plea is murder, which accounts for 19% of the total please.
The insanity defense is widely used in tv dramas and is popular among court cases shown in local and national news. Those who use the mnaghten rule of law, those who use the american law institute ali model penal code, and those who have abolished the use of the insanity defense. Combining legal thriller with tracking a serial killer, thompson once again takes the reader on a helluva ride, right up to the last page and sentence. Based on a actual 8year love affair she had with an american artist named thelma wood, barnes chronicles the destructive love life of. Little is known about the criminal justice system and the mentally ill. Compiled by members of a harvard seminar, it directs attention to the issues most often raised by the general. Thinking about the insanity defense answers ninetyseven frequently asked questions and presents sixteen case examples in easily understood language. Over the past 15 years, we have gathered information about serial killers.
Insanity defense wex us law lii legal information institute. The hidden history of the suv next time on frontline. The bell jar by sylvia plath, one flew over the cuckoos nest by ken kesey, fight club by chuck palahniuk, insanity by cameron. The insanity defense a perplexing problem of criminal. Insanity defense as a history of mental disorder oxford handbooks. The simple fact that there is a distinction between those who commit a crime as a symptom of a mental. And in the end, it is still up to the jury or judge to accept or reject an insanity plea.
Nevertheless, he had sufficient mental capacity to sue his former psychiatrist for failing to. Apr 26, 20 barnes herself called this novel of illfated passions the story of a soul talking to itself in the heart of the night. The insanity defense a perplexing problem of criminal justice dale e. Furthermore, the statistics brought about by silver and colleagues 1994 prove that there is a societal bias against the insanity plea. Key facts to know about the insanity defense armstrong. He was also one of the most prolific serial killers in u. Thompson in his new book, the insanity plea published by story merchant books brings us into the life of wayne little. The use and effectiveness of the insanity plea by serial killers jana l. Key facts to know about the insanity defense armstrong law. Personally, i dont believe that the insanity plea should be abolished, only because mental health is a real problem.
The controversial insanity defense service catalog. More importantly, the public could rest assured that a person committed to a mental institution would not. Sep 29, 2012 the insanity defense presents many difficult questions for the legal system. List of books and articles about insanity defense online. The controversial insanity defense the insanity defense is often used by people who are not medically diagnosed with a psychological disorder and this leads to the risk of acquitting guilty people who deserve to be punished. Unfortunately, however, the debate has been dominated by slogans and stereotypes and by an inappropriate array of law against psychiatry, retribution. Not guilty by reason of insanity generally requires that as a result of mental illness the defendant was unable to distinguish right from wrong at the time. As time progressed, advancements were made, particularly in england, where the views of the insanity defense changed over time, and led up to the mcnaughton rules. A powerful and humane exploration of the history of the insanity defense, through the story of one poignant case. The insanity defense, also known as the mental disorder defense, is an affirmative defense by excuse in a criminal case, arguing that the defendant is not responsible for their actions due to an episodic or persistent psychiatric disease at the time of the criminal act. The ali test provided that a person was not responsible for criminal conduct if, at the time of the act, the person lacked. S criminal justice system in less than 1% of all criminal cases. A moving target one thing that may not be apparent to those who read about cases or hear about them on television is that the insanity defense standard is not static.
It used some sort of insanity defense mental state defense, 2008. More importantly, the public could rest assured that a person committed to a mental institution would not be walking the streets anytime in the near future if ever. But courts and legislatures have been slow to make changes. A young nurse is savagely killed during a predawn run on galvestons seawall. Early implications of the insanity defense history of. The truth is, the insanity defense is a rarely invoked plea in the united states. A defendant claiming the defense is pleading not guilty by reason of insanity ngri or guilty but insane or mentally ill in some. The courts initial verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity generated public outcry and renewed interest in the verdict of guilty but mentally ill, which is permissible in some states. The murderer slices her running shorts from her body as his trophy and tosses the body over the wall to the rocks below.
690 458 726 392 389 1379 676 1114 706 186 1602 973 40 542 180 260 333 668 426 239 1174 175 689 1029 484 422 734 1240 942 824 351 485 30 138 490 1084 1285 537 1224 764 141